Home

Every day, without fail, your Facebook or Twitter feeds are cluttered by articles with headlines like “X reasons why you are bad at life” or “10 things you must do before [insert arbitrary activity or life event here]”. Some of it is for pure entertainment, while others attempt to offer sage advice for leading a better life.  It’d be nice if the secret to success and everlasting happiness could be found in a neatly compiled list, but I’m here to call bullshit on that. Here’s 5 reasons why you shouldn’t take life advice from lists on life advice:

  1. Most of those lists suck– There, I said it. Most of the lists out there suck. If you happen to follow sites like Elite Daily, you’ll see how trivial and vapid some people’s view on life is. They make us generation Y’ers in particular sound like whiny, egotistical children trapped in adult bodies with internet access and a modest grasp of the English language.
  2. They attempt to pidgeonhole people and complex life issues- For something as complex as our individual lives and choices, is it truly wise to seek insight from a list that someone else made? Let’s face it, we really look to these lists to validate certain feelings that we have that we’re perhaps too afraid to admit to ourselves or voice to friends. There is no insight to be had here folks – so no, men will not magically learn what women want by reading a list of things that she secretly wishes he would know (c’mon, you should already know that us men don’t read instructions anyway) – but it will validate the hell out of some feelings that you have in your own personal interactions.
  3. Some people will actually take the advice to heart – Now, I’ll go ahead and say most of us (the author included) are guilty of reposting an interesting list article here and there. But then there are other people on your timeline – the ones who repost these things incessantly, usually with a comment along the lines of “This is so me! Each one is sooooo true!” Those articles will usually have a title like “5 reasons why you should only have one night stands until you’re at least 25” or “10 ways being a douchebag will actually help you be successful in life.” It’s bad enough that there are people actually writing this crap. We don’t need more people spreading it around as if its gospel.
  4. The writers usually have no idea what they’re talking about (or may have been intoxicated while writing it) – This goes back to what was said in the first point, but I just wanted to reiterate how bad these things can really be.
  5. They’re unreliable sources of information – This list is a great example. I promised 5 reasons but can only come up with 4 (and the forth is really half-assed). So there. Yeah…

There you have it folks: Five reasons why you should never take life advice from a list on life advice. I hope you join me for my next article on finding your life purpose through the quizzes on Buzzfeed.

4 thoughts on “5 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Take Life Advice from Lists on Life Advice

  1. Sir Martin, thanks for sharing your blog in one of Elite Daily’s “dating” articles’ comments.
    You are on point with this!
    Might I add (to your pt. #5) further, these typical Lists articles (especially from Elite D.) are mostly based on personal views and not on scientific studies. Therefore, people shouldn’t really take these articles seriously to heart as you stated as they don’t have any scientific backing to make them relatable to the general population.
    How dare this “journalist” tell me this certain type of girl is bad for me when he/she doesn’t have a study to prove this? =D

    Like

    • Hey Lo! Thanks for coming by and reading, it’s much appreciated. I agree with your addition, as much of the stuff they tend to put out insinuates that their list is empirical and usually has no basis in any kind of theories that are backed by research. Personally, I think Elite Daily could actually do good if they weren’t so obsessed with just generating traffic. They have the audience to be a true voice of our generation, and they use it to promote crap which makes all of us look bad.

      Since you found me through the Nice Guy post, I was wondering if you had a chance to take a look at my post there and what your thoughts are.

      Like

  2. Dude, check out this great investigate work from theawl.com about Elite Daily if you haven’t. I came across this article months back when I was reading about Blog sites that generate huge traffic. The article is from last year so I’m not sure if things have changed since then.

    It’s about ED’s use of pseudonyms, list posts, and intentional controversial articles to generate traffic. Funny thing is, one of the aforementioned made-up writer profile was from the same guy who made that “nice guy/ bad guy” article! =D

    http://www.theawl.com/2013/07/rich-kids-of-the-internet-inside-the-astounding-troll-hole-that-is-elite-daily

    Like

    • Haha yes! I’ve read that article before. Great investigative work by the author. I was wondering for a second why I recognized Paul Hudson’s name – it was like having a case of deja vu when I read the Nice Guy article. It’s such a shame that one of the first platforms that can be used to give a voice to Gen Y is just a bunch of dorky, angst-y rich kids posting lame articles on misconceptions of life which they pass off as “almost-fact”.

      Like

Leave a comment